Love + Sex

Friday, November 27, 2009

When Do Guys Think a Boob Job Is Warranted?

Advice from three of our guy friends. This week a straight woman asks, "I think my boobs are too small -- slightly pudgy guys have bigger boobs than me! Should I get a boob job?"

Gay Committed Guy (Mark): Gut response: No. Even though god knows how many Americans have some kind of body-image hangup, I don't think "society" is shaming those pudgy guys into getting lipo on their manboobs in order to look more attractive to women. That said, if you think the pain and possible health risks associated with surgery and/or implants are worth it -- if you really think it would improve your self-esteem, and you've exhausted all other options toward that end -- it's your decision. Anyone who tells you that you "should" get a boob job is either a creep or a plastic surgeon or an editor at Us Weekly magazine (the latter of which will be the first to mock your new rack for looking fake). I have friends who have had minor work done -- breasts (adding and subtracting), eyes, nose, thighs, tummy -- and they've all been pleased with the results. Obviously, if you do decide to go through with it, find a reputable doctor, and don't go overboard with ridiculous porn-star balloons that are out of proportion with the rest of your body.

Straight Single Guy (Max): It kills me not to automatically say "Don't do it!", but I think it actually depends on a couple of things. Confidence, as you know, matters more than most factors when it comes to attraction. If you can't talk to a guy because you're too self conscious about the size of your boobs, then you need to do something. But plastic surgery might not be the answer. Boobs, as I and most guys see them, are always and only bonuses. If a girl has nice boobs, that's great. But I'm not going to see a girl and think "Man, if she only had bigger boobs..." That's just stupid. (If, however, this is the kind of guy you want, then by all means, get a boob job.) Personally, I think fake boobs are gross. I believe that most guys agree, no matter how much porn would have you believe otherwise. But again, you gotta do what makes you feel sexy. (Oh, and please don't compare yourself to pudgy guys. That's the first step in gaining a little self confidence.)

More...

Straight Married Guy (Ben): My wife's boobs have changed sooo much over the course of our relationship -- from tiny to a handful to size F after our baby was born (we didn't even know they made size F!) and then back to C. Each step of the way I've been right there enjoying them. It's actually been one of the most amazing things about her body. That's not to say your boobs are one day going to blossom or grow, but what's made my wife's body so immensely pleasurable for me and for her is her own comfort and confidence with it. Sexy does not equal boob size. Sexy equals feeling good and being confident in yourself and your sexuality. I say, learn to rock those nubs! You can always get the surgery later. Or have a baby.

MORE BOOBIE TOPICS FROM EM & LO:

Our “wise guys” are a rotating group of contributors, some of whom wish to remain anonymous and some of whom like the attention. This week's Straight Married Guy is Ben, a writer and artist living in Los Angeles who runs AdultParlorGames.com. Our Committed Gay Guy, Mark, is a writer and teacher in NYC and our Single Straight Guy, Max, is a recent college grad in New England -- both asked us to file them under "shy." To ask the guys your own question, click here.

photo by PinkMoose
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 25
  • Guy's Avatar
    Posted by Guy Wed Sep 16, 2009 10:34pm PDT

    I don't like boob jobs, it shows (and I mean SHOWS) that a woman is insecure. Also, there isn't a boob job ever performed that looks natural, I can spot a boob job a mile away: they are too round and spaced too far apart. I guess if a woman had an A-cup then I wouldn't be so judgemental because I guess that they don't have a lot of clothes to choose from. Anyways, if you are a good person then we don't really care anyways. I've dated women with sizes A through D so it just goes to show that it isn't THAT important. If you just want attention from a bunch of random guys then that is what a boob job will get you.

    Report Abuse
  • Tigs's Avatar
    Posted by Tigs Wed Sep 16, 2009 11:23pm PDT

    I think that women get a lot of grief if they have boobs that are too small and the instant go to method of having a larger cup size is to get plastic surgery. There are other methods a woman can use like going on the birth control pill.

    Women who have a smaller bust size have a greater advantage. We don't have back pain from carrying huge knockers day in and day out and when we get older, they don't sag. My boyfriend says he likes my small size because he can nestle them in his hands and they're not flopping all over the place when night time comes.

    Report Abuse
  • freewillove's Avatar
    Posted by freewillove Thu Sep 17, 2009 2:02am PDT

    Little dose not matter what matter how healthy the person.

    Apply medicate to enhance boob is not that good let leave it have nature made it to be.

    As long it fit the body.

    Can produce milk.

    No cancer.

    Let it be some appear like pimple but after birth it develope some even extra large.

    Thanks

    Report Abuse
  • Vodwine's Avatar
    Posted by Vodwine Thu Sep 17, 2009 4:41am PDT

    Any surgery is a risky surgery and should only be performed when its absolutely necessary. I feel that a person needs to be pround of themselves with how they are and not try to change/transform themselves into something else that they feel society stereotypes as a womanly figure.

    The only time I feel that a breast augmentation maybe justified is if a woman loses a breast(s) from breast cancer or if her breasts are Serverly disformed or disfigured and it inhibits or interferes with breast feeding.

    Report Abuse
  • None's Avatar
    Posted by None Thu Sep 17, 2009 5:29am PDT

    Take hormones jeez! Do it the all natural way! If a man can get breasts when he is transforming into a she, why can't a woman do it? But do what makes you happy, but I find boob jobs gross looking and you lose feeling, but if you are like flat as a board, I can understand it, but do it for YOU, if it makes you happy then go for it.

    Report Abuse
  • Ashley's Avatar
    Posted by Ashley Thu Sep 17, 2009 5:34am PDT

    wow this is kinda a weird comment for strangers to read lol

    Report Abuse
  • promise's Avatar
    Posted by promise Thu Sep 17, 2009 5:37am PDT

    i followed the link to "what do guys really think about fake boobs?" and i was pleased with what most the men said! basically that they dont like fake breasts, and big or small they just like them. lol i have small boobs and i will admit breast implants crossed my mind, but i dont want to be like every other girl with fake boobs (so many have them now!) ill keep it natural and love them!

    Report Abuse
  • spotty's Avatar
    Posted by spotty Thu Sep 17, 2009 6:01am PDT

    Who cares what men think about it. They are the scum that INVENTED fake boobs and thousands of women have been hurt or disfigured in an effort to please an un-pleaseable animal, men. They are not only aesthetically gross but a huge conspiracy AGAINST women. To keep women unhappy about their appearance not being that of a plastic doll is the goal of men who don't want women to reach their true potential. JUST SAY NO TO FAKE!

    Report Abuse
  • chrissyr's Avatar
    Posted by chrissyr Thu Sep 17, 2009 6:09am PDT

    before kids i was a c cup. after breastfeeding 3 children i am now an a, almost b cup. i have often thought of getting augmentation, if i could ever afford it! after reading this i might just invest in a wonderbra instead. thank you, wise guys!

    Report Abuse
  • Psychic  E.S.'s Avatar
    Posted by Psychic E.S. Thu Sep 17, 2009 6:17am PDT

    No, None, (above) that advice is all wrong,hormones are delicate chemistry. You don't just take a pill & 'watch something happen'. Anyone knows that hoemones are much more complicated than that. I'm a firm believer in plastic surgery. I think it's great that you can either change or enhance your appearence if you so desire,& I've always thought like that. So then it was easy for me to decide to go from a pear shape to an hour glass. I got beautiful results, & I look totally natural, so really there's nothing for any man to think one way or the other. I do however appreciate the nice compliment I recieved last week; "You are a beautiful creature, & you have such a stunning figure." Every woman deserves to hear that anyway, no matter what choices she makes about her appearance.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 25

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?