Love + Sex

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

He's Perfect... Except for the Sex. Can I Marry Him?


To submit your own advice question to Em & Lo, click here.

Dear Em & Lo,

This may sound pathetic, but the guy I am dating is perfect for me, I love him and want him as my husband, but I don’t really enjoy our sex life.  It’s two and a half years in and I don’t think it’s going to get much better.  I know what I could have in that department and even where to get it, it’s just not with my BF.  Is the only way forward to get out and wait for everything to be perfect?   My mom, of course, wants me to get married, but I am only 27 and don’t want to spend the next 20 years thinking about being unfaithful, which has happened once already.  Please, which way is up?

– Can’t Get No Satisfaction

Dear C.G.N.S.,

Hmm…looks like we disagree on our definitions of “perfect.” Where we come from, “perfect” means someone who complements you emotionally, spiritually, physically — the whole soulmate package, ya know? It sounds like your guy would make a perfect platonic soulmate…but it doesn’t sound like that’s going to satisfy you.

If we were your mom, we would tell you that 27 is too young to settle for less than a soulmate. Hell, 47 is too young to settle for less than a soulmate. And we’re not even talking perfect soulmates, here — just strong, solid relationships without huge gaping holes in them. After all, good relationships are built on compromise — but there’s a big difference between compromise and settling. And marrying a guy who totally doesn’t do it for you in the sack is definitely settling, especially at 27.

We’re assuming from your letter that you’ve tried everything already — communication, experimentation, etc. — to improve your sex life. If not, then that’s obviously your first step. If this guy is all that you say he is, he clearly deserves a chance to satisfy you. Does he even know how unhappy you are in bed? If you’re not ready to let him go, then your one chance of making things work is addressing the issue together. Gently. You might even want to consider seeing a counselor together for a bit of guidance.

Also, make sure you’re being realistic about sex and long-term relationships. That awesome sexual excitement you get from a new love wears off after about two years (studies have actually proven it). And often, what makes sex exciting is the taboo, the new, the unknown. You have to work hard to hold on to those things in a long-term relationship, but they are automatic with a one-night stand/a fling/a booty call/someone you just start seeing — because it’s uncharted territory. Take this mysterious third party you know you can get hot lovin’ from — are you sure the main reason it’s so hot isn’t simply because he’s forbidden? Imagine what it would be like in a long-term relationship with this sex machine two and a half years from now. Would there even be a relationship?

We’d go into more detail, except that we have a feeling it’s more than just a lack of communication or realism on your part. You obviously know what sexual chemistry is and it sounds like you and your boyfriend don’t have even a smidge of it. Plus, it sounds like sexual chemistry is really important to you — some people could take it or leave it, but if you’re thinking about a life of infidelity just to get that chemistry, then you’re not one of those people. In which case, poppet, DO NOT MARRY THIS MAN! Sure, in the course of decades of marriage, your attraction to your spouse may come and go — eventually, when you’re old and grey, it may well go and never come back. But that’s a long way off, so if the chemistry isn’t there in the first place, what hope do you two have of making it in this cold cruel world? Especially if you’ve already cheated on your guy once.

Do yourself — and this awesome guy — a favor: if some communication, experimentation, and a roll of bondage tape don’t create a little more heat between you two, then let him go. Don’t worry about what your mom says: She’ll get over your breakup a hell of a lot more quickly than she would your divorce from him five years from now. And as everybody else’s mom would say: Plenty more fish in the sea.

IOHO,

Em & Lo

To submit your own advice question, click here.

MORE FROM EM & LO:

photo by jeroen_bennink

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 27
  • another hockey fan's Avatar
    Posted by another hockey fan Mon Oct 19, 2009 1:40pm PDT

    You've already been unfaithful once and thank goodness you are thinking seriously about the potential of it happening again if you were to marry this man. He may seem "perfect" but no man or woman is perfect and obviously you've already found at least one important thing you don't like. On another note, please don't marry a man because your family or friends think you should or even if they think he's the right guy either. They don't have to live with him!! I hope you end this relationship and be honest in that you don't see a future. You don't have to mention the sex. It's only fair to do it now before you both end up regretting it all together. You will be very glad you did down the road.

    Report Abuse
  • BelenW's Avatar
    Posted by BelenW Mon Oct 19, 2009 3:09pm PDT

    Yes, they are right don't marry him. I met a man that I really liked too, but same thing he is awful in bed. Plus he can never get a complete erection. I have made suggestiona of other way to satisfy me but he is too self absorbed. He has not called me which is good so, I don't have to break it off or try to find a reason without hurting his feelings.

    Report Abuse
  • Cara's Avatar
    Posted by Cara Mon Oct 19, 2009 3:12pm PDT

    NNNNNNOOOOOOO don't marry the poor guy. He probably doesn't even know how unhappy you are - if your reaction to sex with him isn't hot and happy and he doesn't know it, it's his MO. As far as counseling goes - who goes to counseling BEFORE they get married. Why would you ever do that? If you are in trouble now, you are really in trouble after the wedding. You have a right to a happy, healthy life that includes great sex. It is entirely too much to give up for a "nice guy". Look for your soul mate - he's out there looking for you. Your Mom loves you, she'll get over him.

    Report Abuse
  • curiously's Avatar
    Posted by curiously Mon Oct 19, 2009 4:09pm PDT

    "when is about sex or friendship they should think about things: the future of things and the substance of things" lol

    - I understand that the prelude is important but if the prelude takes too much time, most men risks to lose their interest... Say it what you want but on this counts persons that has not interest in sex. The question is: are you implying or at least are you willing to do sex with him? Being a man, I know very well that expression "yes I do, but not with you", nothing new ... :-)

    - had you ever think that possible are you intimidating him with something? It's hard for men to make great sex or even sex especially when we are intimidated by something.

    ..... Observation: how better can be the sex in these two conditions when it is proved that only one condition from these two can decrease the men libidos?

    - from what you said, you suggested that you prefer one kind of sex (a desirable sex) and he can't perform that kind of sex (nice for you). Contrarily of what you suggested at the subconscious level (that he is not great in bed generally speaking), from this don't results that he can't perform great sex at all with other woman. I understand that there can be bad news for you and I am sorry for this.

    - I think that there is also about the compatibilites/incompatibilities :-)

    - I believe that there is an incredible difference between the subjective approach and the objective approach. Like you said, your sex seems to be in a way or another disastrous. But still the subjective approaches express subjective wills (I don't comment such kind of things). Contrarily, the objective approaches are about the nature of things. How can we expect to have a perfect sex, or at least a great sex, or at least a nice sex, or at least sex (after all), when we do nothing at least to try to change the nature of things?

    O_o

    Report Abuse
  • Qutonya's Avatar
    Posted by Qutonya Mon Oct 19, 2009 4:31pm PDT

    If you really love him then go for it. You can also try to heat up the passion. Sex is important but love is too.

    Report Abuse
  • LeDerrick's Avatar
    Posted by LeDerrick Mon Oct 19, 2009 4:58pm PDT

    Okay. I feel your anguish.. Check this out! Visual erotica is by far and away, the easiest way to "inform" your man of your "real" needs. From reading your opening, it would appear that since you "know WHAT and where to get WHAT you need to enjoy sex", perhaps whats missing is "outrageously good sex." Outrageously good sex is created by the one who will venture beyond the everyday normal routines in the bedroom, and go where no woman has gone before... I have found that women truly know where this "place" is. First, get yourself candles, oils, creams and an electronic "device." Throw in some lingerie that would make a w---- blush, then secretly invite your lover to "watch" you silently, and up close and personal. If you are half as interested in sex as you let on, then even Stevie Wonder and Larry Flynnt would want to join in. The rest is up to you. Last but not least, stop listening to and/or taking any more advice. Its time to put up or shut up. Stop dreamin and start creamin... PLEASE, LET US ALL KNOW YOUR RESULTS...

    Report Abuse
  • SILENT KNIGHT's Avatar
    Posted by SILENT KNIGHT Mon Oct 19, 2009 5:50pm PDT

    Sure she can marry him if she doesn't mind the inactivity down stairs. It happens all the time and that's why some wives lead more exciting lives than others.

    Report Abuse
  • Zom-B's Avatar
    Posted by Zom-B Mon Oct 19, 2009 6:24pm PDT

    Hmmm...

    Now, I wonder what the reaction would be if it were a man who cheated because his girlfriend was the one who was sexually unsatisfying??

    Anyone want to take bets that there would be considerably less sympathy?

    I thought not.

    Report Abuse
  • Marzella912's Avatar
    Posted by Marzella912 Mon Oct 19, 2009 6:56pm PDT

    I had this same problem about a year ago with my ex..He asked me to marry him,but the SEX was terrible. All I could think about was, the SEX and what it would be like 10,15 years down the road. There just wasn't any sparks, and no SEX isn't everything but when it comes down to making a commitment at such a young age it makes a big difference, I was only 24 at the time, so You may just have to let it go, I'm glad I did.

    Report Abuse
  • HEATHER's Avatar
    Posted by HEATHER Tue Oct 20, 2009 12:11am PDT

    "If you really love him then go for it. You can also try to heat up the passion. Sex is important but love is too."

    SEX is more important than LOVE?

    lol you're crazy.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 27

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?