Parenting

Friday, November 27, 2009

How's That Working For You? Thanks a lot Dr. Phil



Katie and I recently were invited to appear on The Dr. Phil show to do a segment about teen stress.

Our segment covered "Applying To College", and we were to discuss how the entire college application process has left Katie not sure why she is expected to know what she is going to do with her life at age 17 and me not sure why this isn't as exciting as I thought it was going to be. Weren't we supposed to be going on mother-daughter weekends to footballs games while visiting college towns across the country?


As we sat in the front row, waiting for our turn with the good doctor, we listened to a story about a mom who pushed her 10-year old daughter to twirl her baton and compete in pageants even though the little girl didn't want to anymore and the family was near bankruptcy. Turns out, as Dr. Phil cleverly led us all to see, it was the mom who really wanted to be a baton twirler and never reached her own dream of drill team. As a result, the mom was pushing her daughter to achieve for her. (I made a note to myself that I didn't care if Katie twirled a baton or not, so I was safe.)

The next story was about a dad who injected his 12-year old son with steroids in order for the son to win competitions and Daddy Dearest is currently serving prison time. The son is now 20 years old and seems like he's had a rough time putting his life back together. (I made another note to myself that I was doing ok since I've never injected Katie with anything. Jeez, I can't even get her to take vitamins.)

As the show neared our segment, I started to worry about what kind of deep horrible secret Dr. Phil was going to pull out about me. I could hear him say his famous "How's that working for you?" or "You've got to have a clear agenda in order to be an effective parent." I could feel my palms starting to sweat. I really wanted to throw up.


And then the cameras turned on us...


Dr. Phil asked Katie what was going on with college and she said in her mature, poised, matter-of-fact way that she felt there is too much pressure on kids today to make decisions about their lives at age 17 and that too many parents aren't letting kids explore options. He asked Katie what other things she was thinking about doing instead of going right into college. Now I was confident that she wasn't going to say "make hemp bracelets and hang-out at the beach all day", but I was moderately curious about what was going to pop out of her mouth in that nano-second. I could feel the sigh of relief when she said she'd like to explore a gap year or return to Africa to do more community service (yes, see, no hemp bracelets). I smiled thinking that this kid is good. She's a natural on camera, in front of an audience. She should really have her own show.

I was beaming until I realized the attention had turned to me. Oh, right. What's my problem?

Katie seems like "an exemplary young teenager", according to Phil. As I yammered on about god only knows what, Dr. Phil looked me in the eyes and told me exactly what my problem was. He quoted leading educators and their studies that show how kids who take a gap year actually do better in college than those who go right into college. He said that he bets I'm afraid that if she doesn't go right into school, she won't go at all. Sounded good to me, so I said "Yep. That's exactly what is wrong." I had seen how he brought the baton twirling mom to her own awakening and I wasn't ready for that kind of come-to-Jesus moment on national television, so I agreed. Why bring up family expectations or the lack of future jobs for these kids or, dare I say, foreign talent competition. Nope. I stuck to his story.


And then the worst thing of all happened. I kept talking. I couldn't shut up. I went on to say how sad I was that Katie was leaving home and how maybe my not wanting her to go is a problem and what is really holding her back AND THEN I STARTED TO CRY. Katie was horrified and I could sense the shock and disgust as she watched me choke up right then and there on Dr. Phil about her leaving home. After the show, we sat in stony silence as we were driven back to the hotel in our big, black studio car. I knew she hated me and I was still reeling from my big reveal. Dr. Phil is good. He found the hole in the dam and I didn't even know there was one. I finally told her I'd take her to Fred Segal or Robertson Ave for a little shopping before our flight and that seemed to finally break the ice.

Oh well. Now my secret is out: I'm a mom that is having trouble letting go and the real reason I'm stressing out about my daughter not going away to college is that I'll selfishly be thrilled to have her home and with me for another year or two. And truth be told, she is really talented at making jewelry and I bet she'd make one heck of a hemp bracelet!
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 48
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Mon Oct 12, 2009 3:19pm PDT

    Too long....

    Report Abuse
  • Sarah Y's Avatar
    Posted by Sarah Y Mon Oct 12, 2009 4:00pm PDT

    I think you explained your feelings really well. I don't think I would want to go on Dr. Phil to figure all of that out. (Like you said, you don't want to have a break-down on national TV.) But, maybe now that it is out in the open, it will be easier to talk to your daughter about your feelings.

    Report Abuse
  • Arizona's Avatar
    Posted by Arizona Tue Oct 13, 2009 8:18am PDT

    Good for your daughter and bravo to you! At 27, looking back at 17, I just can't believe I was expected to make such a choice before I'd even left high school. I took general ed classes two at a time for a couple of years and switched majors probably four times. What I probably should have done was take a full year or two off but, still, it worked out for me.

    Finally, I developed a passion for something that I lacked at 17. In community college, I was Phi Beta Kappa and at the University, Dean's List. I've learned to network and understand it's value. Some, not all of course but, some 17 or 18 year olds are just too immature to get it. I don't think I would have enjoyed or excelled at my chosen path as a teenager as I do now. I just wasn't ready.

    Best of luck to you both!!

    Report Abuse
  • Mira Jacob, Shine staff's Avatar
    Posted by Mira Jacob, Shine staff Tue Oct 13, 2009 8:45am PDT

    Kristy, what a great story. You might be embarrassed now, but I think you handled yourself really well, and kudos for being able to listen to Katie at the risk of being embarrassed by Dr. Phil on national television. That's good parenting, and your crying doesn't change that. (In fact, it's sweet. And totally reasonable, given the situation. I would have bawled like a baby the minute I hit the set.)

    Report Abuse
  • siri's Avatar
    Posted by siri Tue Oct 13, 2009 9:07am PDT

    Kristy, As I read your story my heart went out to you. I'm so glad you shared it and happy to know I'm not the only mom who felt that way and whose gone through pretty much the same ordeal! Being in the hot-seat in group therapy. And btw... knowing this was the last thing one thinks they're going to speak of or share. Great post.

    Thanks for sharing!

    Report Abuse
  • "Mama Kaye"'s Avatar
    Posted by "Mama Kaye" Tue Oct 13, 2009 9:35am PDT

    Thanks for sharing your experience.A story worth telling takes time and you did it very well.

    Report Abuse
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Tue Oct 13, 2009 10:01am PDT

    BRAVO!!!!!!!!!!!!! My daughter is only 6, but I know one day will come when she will want to "move on"...it completely breaks my heart. I love your story.

    Report Abuse
  • starfedra's Avatar
    Posted by starfedra Tue Oct 13, 2009 11:42am PDT

    I think I will have the same problem when my daughter turns 17, she is only 4 now but she is such a bright mind, she is reading already and asking questions beyond her age, I am sure she will want to do great things in the world but I will have a really hard time letting go, I already can see it...!! Great article..

    Report Abuse
  • ?'s Avatar
    Posted by ? Tue Oct 13, 2009 1:45pm PDT

    Kids are supposed to leave home, wish mine would. They are all adults now, one has even bounced back in this economy. I am glad I have a place for him to land for a while, but I am looking forward to the day they all leave for good. I will miss them. I love them will all my heart and will do everything within my power for them, but I still want them to go! I always did, even when they were little. My goal was to raise independent adults, not clingy whiners.

    Report Abuse
  • Frantastic's Avatar
    Posted by Frantastic Tue Oct 13, 2009 3:00pm PDT

    I think the closer the time comes, most are bitter sweet. Part of you is ready for them to go out into the world and make their mark. Part of you wants to tag along and see what exactly they will do. Most kids don't know what they want at that age. The economy is forcing most to attend a JC and stay home for awhile.(no need in helping to pay two rents ie mortgage.) They are the only ones that truly know. I have an 18 and 17 yr old. We aren't having their suitcases packed at the graduation. It is very hard and challenging. Being supportive and not pushy is best. Not forcing a decision on them.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 48

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.