Manage Your Life

Thursday, November 26, 2009

Will "Generation Y" reinvent the workplace?

A recent article from Psychology Today contends that Millennials (individuals born roughly from the early 1980s through the late 1990s, also known as Generation Y) are poised to take over the workplace.

The article declares that these newest entrants to the workforce were "raised by parents who often acted more like friends and mentors. So Gen Y comes to the negotiating table with unprecedented confidence about what kind of workplace they want.”

When I read articles like this, I’m of two minds. On one hand, I’m endlessly fascinated with the different generational characteristics that researchers have discovered between Generation X, Generation Y and Baby Boomers. On the other hand, descriptions about the characteristics of these generations often sound like they’ve come out of a fortune cookie or horoscope. Take this quote from that Psychology Today article:

Gen Y prefers to work in teams not by themselves and they hate conflict. Gen Y are not complainers, nor act like victims. They are hard workers and want to have work that its challenging.



So much of it doesn’t ring true to me. First, it often smacks of elitism because it focuses primarily on the children of the wealthy, well-educated parents. (This Gawker post says it all -- as does the Washington Post article on which it was based).  Second, it speaks in sweeping generalizations. How can a whole generation be “hard workers who don’t act like victims”?  And finally, so many of the characteristics of the generations bleed into each other so that boomers try to emulate the texting and Facebooking ways of their children while high schoolers check their Blackberries on the soccer field because they are mirroring their parents’ behavior. (This is why I love this post by Penelope Trunk offering a new way to think about which generation you belong to.)

What do you think -- is there truth to all of these stereotypes about the generations or is it just a lot of hype geared to keep consultants in business?

Even if there’s wisdom to the endless chatter about generational differences, are employers still worried about this issue now that they can hire from the vast pool of talented candidates of all ages desperately looking for work?
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 44
  • segakolodi's Avatar
    Posted by segakolodi Tue Jul 14, 2009 6:36am PDT

    WE THE GENERATION Y HAVE A LOT IN COMMON-BEING OF VERY BAD AND GOOD.A LOT OF CHANGES WERE INITIATED BY GEN-X AND WE GEN-Y IMPLEMENTED IT, OTHERS EXAGGERATED SOME ELEMENTS.LETS CHANGE FOR THE BETTER FOLKS..AND HEY THE RECESSION IS MAKING IT WORSE,DIVORCE RATES ARE HIGH AND MARRIEGES ARE NO LONGER RESPECT,PEOPLE HAVE TURNED INTO IRELANDS,MONEY FIRST-NOTHING FOR FREE.HOOOO!WATS GOING ON-LIVING LARGE DOES NOT MEAN YOU HAVE TO HAVE MUCH PRIDE AND LOOSE OTHER PEOPLE IN YOUR LIFE.GEN Y MUST BE ALERT OR ELSE...

    Report Abuse
  • caligirl's Avatar
    Posted by caligirl Tue Jul 14, 2009 8:53am PDT

    becuase i was born in the mid 80's i am a member of the Gen Y. i just think i am a mebmer if the most unorginazed generalation because we are all reaised to me a bunch of "individuals" so as a generation i don't think we will agree on much, let alone how to change the workplace.

    Report Abuse
  • JoKTM's Avatar
    Posted by JoKTM Tue Jul 14, 2009 11:23am PDT

    Every generation changes the work force. At one point intime women were scarce, then dresses had to be worn every day, as women wore pants more then women could wear pants to work and school, people could get paid for vacation days they did not take, now people are scared to take their vacation, women get paid 80cents to the dollar of men, and now tattoos are more common to be seen in the work force.

    Report Abuse
  • Chris S's Avatar
    Posted by Chris S Tue Jul 14, 2009 11:58am PDT

    Currently Gen Y have the highest rate of unemployment. Whether it's experience employers are looking for, which for anyone right out of college, Gen Y doesn't have, or it's the attitude that several have spoken about. I saw it where I worked. The worst was the Gen Y who thought she had the experience to apply for a director position after one year experience (Class of 08). She was upset when told she wasn't going to get an interview and was a spoiled brat for weeks. That's the attitude people don't like and may be trying to keep out of the office.

    Report Abuse
  • Angela's Avatar
    Posted by Angela Tue Jul 14, 2009 12:04pm PDT

    Just FYI, all of your GENERALIZATIONS (you know who you are) are insulting, not to mention inaccurate. We could sit here all day and spout off insulting generalizations about previous generations, but we have to save our time to defend ourselves from the likes of you haters! I'm so glad someone on here finally pointed out that some (lots) of us are HARD WORKING, ACCOMPLISHED, AND EDUCATED and are ABSOLUTELY going to take over the work force; we've already begun!! So thanks to Dayra for standing up for us, cause i was about to get PISSED.

    By the way, I'm 24 with 3 degrees and 2 jobs. Career minded and serious enough for ya?

    Report Abuse
  • Hamed's Avatar
    Posted by Hamed Tue Jul 14, 2009 12:19pm PDT

    may nim is hamed

    iov you

    Report Abuse
  • Katie B's Avatar
    Posted by Katie B Tue Jul 14, 2009 12:47pm PDT

    Angela, I am 27 born in 1981... again depending on which definition you look at I am either a gen xer or a gen yer.... I have brothers and a husband that are in the clear definition of gen yers as they were all born around 1983 or later.... however, like I said in my clarification I really think it has to do with which generation your parents where born in when comparing Gen Y'ers... My parents, my husbands parents and all of my friends and family's parents where Baby Boomers whose parents lived through the Depression... and we are more controlled and less selfish and less entitled than our counterparts.... However, I feel that those whose parents are Gen Xers are more selfish and entitled...

    Again, Yes I am generalizing but I am not saying that ALL Gen. Yers are like this... You may have 3 degrees and 2 jobs but you don't seem to comprehend what I or some others are saying.... we are saying the selfishness is the tendency and is becoming the norm but that there ARE EXCEPTIONS to this trend. It seems to be more prevalent with those born in the very late 80's (ie 88, 89) and the 90's.

    Report Abuse
  • sun2go's Avatar
    Posted by sun2go Tue Jul 14, 2009 1:09pm PDT

    I don't generalize based on an entire generation. It's ignorant & it only spreads misunderstanding. As long as their communication skills aren't limited to how fast they can text or email, or their spelling/grammar skills limited to a word processing checker, I don't care what generation you're from. If you can speak articulately, write intelligently & thoughtfully, you take responsibility for what you do & don't know, and I don't have to look at your buttcrack at work, we're fine.

    Report Abuse
  • Angela's Avatar
    Posted by Angela Tue Jul 14, 2009 1:21pm PDT

    Katie, I definitely comprehended what you were saying, especially now that you've said it three times. I just simply disagree. I guess I just dont like generalizations in general (no pun intended). I'm just not comfortable saying that ANY entire group of people as a whole is selfish, lazy, and not inclined for hard work. And I don't feel that qualifying that grossly generalized statement by going back and saying "oh but of course there are exceptions" makes it any less of an insulting generalization.

    It's unfortunate that many of you have only dealt with a percentage of Generation Y that came across so negatively to you, but I stand by my opinion that it was just that, a small percentage that is not representative of the whole of my generation.

    Report Abuse
  • Angela's Avatar
    Posted by Angela Tue Jul 14, 2009 1:22pm PDT

    Amen on the buttcrack thing, sun2go!! One of the contributions from my generation that i am FAR from proud of ;)

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 44

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

manage your life byte

from Target

All kinds of wonderful. Gifts, solutions and savings all in one place. Find every merry solution at Target.