Manage Your Life

Thursday, November 26, 2009

When to use credit and when to use debit

By Katie McCaskey, Geezeo.com

When should you use your credit card, and when should you use your debit card?

This question is more complicated than it first appears. For example, some people exclusively use their credit card to pay for expenses. They feel this is more secure. Plus, in some instances this means they collect cash back or other incentive points. But this strategy requires a lot of diligence so that the balance can be paid in full at the end of the month. Otherwise you can seriously harm your credit score thanks to a growing debt balance.

day 76 - credit cards

day 76 - credit cards

Image by JudeanPeoplesFront via Flickr

By contrast, using a debit card means that you can only spend what is available in your checking account. Or at least, this is how it used to work…. A few years ago your debit card would be declined if you did not have the balance to cover a purchase. Now, banks are quick to cover your balance and charge you $35 or more for the favor. If you overspend you won’t be stopped at the counter. Instead, you can keep shopping and quickly rack up fees.

Still, there remain some general rule of thumb when to use credit versus debit. Here they are:

Use Debit Cards When….


You Want to Buy Something Inexpensive or Consumable.

It’s hot, you’re thirsty, and you want a soda. If you don’t have cash (first choice!), whip out your debit card. Some merchants have minimal purchase requirements before they will let you use a debit card. Do not put inexpensive purchases or consumable purchases on credit because you’ll end up paying much more for it over time.

You Want to Avoid Lingering Interest Charges.
The quick pain of $35+ might be worth it instead of adding to a growing credit card balance. (If making this choice is your dilemma, consider it a red flag.)

You Need Fast Cash
If you’re in a hurry for cash use your debit card. Preferably use your card at your home bank to avoid ridiculous ATM fees. Taking a cash advance from your credit card will incur a much higher interest rate and could even trigger an interest rate hike on your credit card. Not fun.

Use Credit Cards When…

You Shop Online.
Credit cards offer greater fraud-protection coverage.

You Buy Something Big
Some credit cards offer additional warranty protection beyond the manufacturer. Also, you might be eligible for promotions or additional incentive accumulation offer by the card.

To Establish Credit History

You need to establish solid credit history if you’re just starting out… or starting over. Do so by purchasing an item on the credit card and paying it off entirely at the end of the month or by meeting minimal payment requirements. Note: minimal payments will greatly extend the cost of whatever you’ve purchased.

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 142
  • Emilia's Avatar
    Posted by Emilia Wed Apr 1, 2009 3:36pm PDT

    I pay for everything with my credit card but absolutely always pay the entire balance at the end of the month. I think of it as a debit card with points/ cash back.

    Report Abuse
  • Allison's Avatar
    Posted by Allison Wed Apr 1, 2009 7:48pm PDT

    I always use debit, as I don't believe in credit cards anymore. Got my debt down to $0 years ago, and I will never use a credit card again or ever borrow money again.

    Also since I only use a debit card, I don't have to panic when these stores have their customer information hacked. It's hard to steal credit card info when you don't use credit cards.

    Report Abuse
  • Rose's Avatar
    Posted by Rose Thu Apr 2, 2009 8:40am PDT

    I use my Capital One Credit Card for EVERYTHING. I pay my medical copays, groceries, gas, everything. But the entire balance is deducted every month. I never carry a balance and there is never any finance charges. (Or course I'm pretty thrifty and can say no to just about anything.)

    I love getting my cash back at the end of the year. Each year I get about $500 cash back.

    Capital One will also give you a year end statement and you can see really how much you spent in Restaurants, gas, etc.

    I hate using debit card. I really can't remember that 4 digit pin. That's my "spare" but just keep it for ATMs. Seriously, some places don't even take credit card anymore (like the food court at the mall.) AND I HATE carrying CASH!

    Report Abuse
  • Tricia's Avatar
    Posted by Tricia Tue Apr 7, 2009 3:13am PDT

    I use my credit card for just about everything to that I can earn cash back at the end of the year. I make a payment on my credit card as soon as I use it, so that at the end of the month it is already paid in full.

    Report Abuse
  • lawrence's Avatar
    Posted by lawrence Tue Apr 7, 2009 3:19am PDT

    Debit card information can be hacked and since it comes straight from your bank account, it ties up your assets while it hopefully gets straightened out. Happened to me. That's why, like this article suggested, I use my credit card for online transactions.

    Report Abuse
  • Beauvais David J Atty AtL's Avatar
    Posted by Beauvais David J Atty AtL Tue Apr 7, 2009 3:26am PDT

    I use my debit card only at the ATM. You are much better off if you use credit in other situations no matter how small the purchase is. If your credit card number is compromised, you will get immediate credit while the problem is investigated. When a debit card is compromised, it could empty your bank accout and cause checks to bounce. Even if the bank restores your account balance, the damage has already been done. I see no point in using a debit for anything except getting cash. And you have better protection for disputes with credit transactions. This is a no-brainer.

    Report Abuse
  • timothy g's Avatar
    Posted by timothy g Tue Apr 7, 2009 3:26am PDT

    i use cash for 75 % of what i get

    Report Abuse
  • Effie's Avatar
    Posted by Effie Tue Apr 7, 2009 3:28am PDT

    I have a Check Card with option to be used as Credit or Debit. It works as a Debit Card either way - but I use the Credit Option always as I have extra protection in case of an argument over a purchase.

    Report Abuse
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Tue Apr 7, 2009 3:41am PDT

    I always use debit, to avoid the hassle. As for online? That's what paypal is for.

    Report Abuse
  • James's Avatar
    Posted by James Tue Apr 7, 2009 3:49am PDT

    I AGREE WITH BEAUVAIS--HE NAILED IT.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 142

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

manage your life byte

from Target

All kinds of wonderful. Gifts, solutions and savings all in one place. Find every merry solution at Target.