Healthy Living

Friday, November 27, 2009

User Post: 6 Reasons you aren't losing weight from exercise

We have a close family friend who has struggled with her weight for a good portion of her life.  Brenda has "tried" a lot of things to slim down, but for some reason, never really has been successful.  This last go-round of attempts included an exercise program.  Brenda claimed that she went to the gym 3 times a week for about an hour and a half each visit and that she incorporated weights and cardio.  She hates exercising and yet, she has maintained this regimen for the better part of a year.  Unfortunately, much like her other attempts at losing weight, this too has not been successful.

After asking Brenda a couple of questions to gauge what she was doing while she was at the gym, it became clear to me that Brenda was in a state of delusion...delusion about what she wasn't doing. Stories like these kill me.  Why?  Because people like Brenda think that the act of physically going to the gym means that there will be results.  The truth is, it really isn't that simple.  Just like the 'Lose Weight in 5 Minutes a Day' or 'Burn Fat While You Sleep' schemes...if it sounds too good to be true, it is.  It takes more than five minutes a day of exercise to really see results, it takes more than sleeping to burn fat and it takes more than just 'showing up at the gym' to see the physical benefits of an exercise program.

Delusional mindsets are the biggest saboteurs of fitness programs.  Being realistic and cognizant, however, can be a fitness program's best friends.  So what falls into the realm of delusion?  Here are five typical symptoms of workouts that will not be effective:

  1. Passive Participation: Showing up to the gym is a great starting point, but what you do when you get there is what will actually dictate how effective your workout is.  If you take a class, don't stand in the back of the room half-_ssing your way through the routines.  Get up front and really try.  And if you are working out alone, hold yourself accountable.  Focus and put your full attention and energy into making the workout productive.
  2. Catatonic Cardio: I see it all the time: people moving on cardio equipment at an extremely low intensity or at a snail's pace.  The point of cardio is to work your heart at an intensity of 65% - 85% of your maximum heart rate.  In other words...it should be challenging.  If you are doing aerobic training  and you are 1) not breaking a sweat or 2) capable of holding a full conversation easily, you need to amp up your workout.
  3. Fast and Furious Fitness: We all have days when we can't fit in a full workout, but if you don't put in enough time regularly, you are counteracting anything you ARE putting in.  You should aim to get in 30 - 60 minutes of moderate intensity exercise in each time you workout.
  4. Fair Weather Fan: If you don't exercise regularly enough, you aren't going to see results.  Plain and simple.  If you go one to two times a week, your body isn't getting the exercise it needs to get stronger and healthier.  The reality is, you should aim to get in at LEAST 3 days of cardio and at LEAST 2 - 3 days of strength training each week.
  5. Wimpy Wimpy Weights: Strength training's purpose is to strengthen your muscles.  If you don't challenge them, you won't be strengthening them.  If you are lifting weights and you can do more than 15 repetitions of an exercise without any difficulty, you need to increase the weight to get any benefits out of the exercise.
  6. Nutrition Negligence: Finally, no matter what exercise program you are on...no matter how hard you work out...if you don't eat right, and you neglect a healthy diet, you are completely negating all of the hard work you are doing when you do exercise.  Be sure to eat a healthy diet that is rich with nutrients, vitamins and minerals.

Do you know anyone who is delusional about their exercise program?  Have you ever had any of these 'symptoms'?

Related Topics:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 75
  • KatherineM's Avatar
    Posted by KatherineM Sat Apr 18, 2009 6:42am PDT

    I agree with the information about working out. There is another component to consider - diet! Nasty word! However, I decided a couple of months ago to stop dieting - yes, stop! What did I do to replace this? I chose one aspect of food that I thought I was getting too much of and immediately deleted the component from my diet - in my case, sugar. In the past two months I have gone from size 20 pants to size 12. Can't beat that!! Will stay with this as it provides a healthy way of eating that is also enjoyable - no one needs sugar added to their food.

    Report Abuse
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Sat Apr 18, 2009 11:32am PDT

    Filobur: Very smart. If most people struggling with their weight were aware of the amount of sugar they ate, they would be shocked.

    I also try to avoid sugar as much as possible unless it is from lemons, limes and oranges. It works for me!!!!

    Report Abuse
  • Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance's Avatar
    Posted by Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance Sat Apr 18, 2009 1:05pm PDT

    Yep...sugar is a major nutrition killer.

    Report Abuse
  • Mrs. Carol B's Avatar
    Posted by Mrs. Carol B Wed May 13, 2009 10:55am PDT

    Alcohol consumption is a big reason people keep weight on. I don't eat sweets, drink black coffee, eat protein, keep carbs to a minimum and can't lose a pound. I walk on my treadmill 4 days per week and work an overnight shift in a medical facility 3 nights so I am on my feet 8 out of the 12 hrs. I can't lose a pound. I drink a Scotch or two on my nights off. I know what the culprit is but I like Scotch. It doesn't even give me a buzz so that's not why I drink it. It's like lemonade to me but I can't drink lemonade because of my sensitive tongue. I don't drink sodas because of carbonation which I have to defizz or I bloat up like a hot air balloon. So, I drink very weak Scotch with lots of ice and water and if I don't drink for a month or so which I take holidays several times per year I will lose 1-3 pounds. I either have to become content at a size 12 (145 lbs. 5'2") or give up my Scotch. Hmmmmmm! hard decision. Guess I'll make it tomorrow........

    Report Abuse
  • Missy's Avatar
    Posted by Missy Wed May 13, 2009 12:53pm PDT

    Ha Carol B, that's my problem too. I enjoy red wine too much and would rather drink my calories some nights than eat. I, too, am happy at a size 12.

    Report Abuse
  • Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance's Avatar
    Posted by Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance Wed May 13, 2009 1:16pm PDT

    Carol B...you are dead on. And as we get older, it gets worse. I'm actually in the midst of trying to prepare for an event in a few weeks (friend's wedding)...and I'm not drinking any alcohol until that night. Just so I can look a little lighter...and me too...I don't drink it because I need it...it is because I reallly enjoy a good glass of wine or a vodka cranberry...I hear you.

    Report Abuse
  • Katie B's Avatar
    Posted by Katie B Wed May 13, 2009 1:40pm PDT

    Hm... I know that if I delete Dr. Pepper from my diet I will be much better off... but I love that brown stuff.. I have done better though by only drinking 1-12 oz can a day instead of multiple... it was so bad that it was my water... and I want to exercise and no matter how much I tell myself that I am going to work out for an hour today, it never happens.. something derails that (ie, the house is a mess, hubby is home earlier than usual or whatever other reason I find to derail my schedule) I need will power....

    Report Abuse
  • Julia's Avatar
    Posted by Julia Wed May 13, 2009 1:41pm PDT

    ugh i hear you guys on the alcohol thing.. im turning 21 in 3 weeks and am kinda dreading about my calorie intake. Any of you guys know of some great cocktails that I can have without going overboard on my sugar and calorie intake? any tips would be great. Im a sucker for champagne =/

    Report Abuse
  • susiehomemaker's Avatar
    Posted by susiehomemaker Wed May 13, 2009 5:56pm PDT

    Adding a few glasses of water every day and an apple will work wonders. Even if you don't change anything else, the water will keep your body clean, and the apple will bump up your metabolism with fiber and give your sweet tooth a kick so you don't crave snacks. I've done this and have lost about 6 pounds a month now for 3-4 months. Hit a goal without even trying, and I could've sweated over it for weeks with worse results.

    I do walk at least a mile a day. Outdoors, rain, snow, sleet, or sun. That was nothing new, though.

    Report Abuse
  • Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance's Avatar
    Posted by Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance Wed May 13, 2009 6:04pm PDT

    jbent3....champagne and wine are probably your best bet....hard alcohol has a lot more calories, not to mention the mixers you add to them. If you can tolerate beer...light beer is probably ok too.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 75

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Who doesn't want to look hot at all those holiday parties? ExerciseTV shares how to get in skinny jeans-shape -- and quickly!