Healthy Living

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

7 decades of wacky dieting trends

http://www.tylerlee.net/magcovers/exclusive/lifemag/covers/Life1968/Life19680126.jpg
They may be called fad diets, but, man, these weight-loss ideas sure stick around longer than leggings and platform wedges. The Cookie Diet may have earned some street cred when Jennifer Hudson was associated with trying it, but the plan got its start in the ’70s. And that Master Cleanse Beyoncé reportedly used to slim down? It’s probably older than your mom. Read on for more ways women have fought fat for the past century. Note: Some are really bizarre and unhealthy.

1930s-’40s diet trends: Smoking and the Master Cleanse Models and celebrities must have gotten the idea that smoking keeps you thin from somewhere, right? It turns out a 1920s-’30s ad campaign is to blame. Cigarette brand Lucky Strike used the line “Reach for a Lucky Instead of a Sweet.” Ugh! Do we even need to remind you of all the reasons—infertility, heart disease, lung cancer—smoking is one of the unhealthiest habits for you? Women looking for a quicker fix opted for the lemonade diet, or Master Cleanse. Developed by Stanley Burroughs, the diet allowed only lemon juice, cayenne pepper and maple syrup. Nearly 70 years later, Beyoncé reportedly used the same program to shed pounds for her role in 2006’s Dreamgirls. Talk about staying power!

Don't try these other scary celeb diet tricks!

1950s diet trend: Prayer
Want to drop pounds? Pray for weight loss. The idea may sound nutty to some, but in the 1950s, the Christian dieting industry exploded. After losing 100 pounds, Reverend Charlie Shedd wrote the book Pray Your Weight Away, which was published in 1957. The best-seller set the trend for future titles such as I Prayed Myself Slim (1960), Help Lord, The Devil Wants Me Fat! (1978) and The Weigh Down Diet (1997), which advised readers not to confuse physical hunger for what was really spiritual hunger. Think this trend has died? Think again. In 2002, Don Colbert, M.D., published What Would Jesus Eat? and The What Would Jesus Eat Cookbook.

1960s diet trend: Support groups and cabbage soup
The ’60s were all about sharing the love, and the concept even applied to dieting. Dieters began forming support organizations. Early in the decade, a group of compulsive eaters formed Overeaters Anonymous. And in 1961, Jean Nidetch invited friends into her New York City home to talk about weight loss. Two years later, after losing 72 pounds, she launched Weight Watchers. But dieting wasn’t always so friendly. The Cabbage Soup Diet was published in a book during this time. It promised dieters they would lose 17 pounds, but users mentioned the gassy side effects—not exactly conducive to close encounters, huh?

Need to lose weight fast? Try these healthy "crash" diets.

1970s diet trend: Diet pills The era touted the miracle of diet pills. Some claimed to stop the body’s absorption of carbs. In essence, they promised you could stuff your face with pizza and bread without consequences. After reports of vomiting and abdominal pain, however, the FDA pulled the pills in 1983 to investigate the long-term side effects. This turned out to be a good thing because researchers found that the undigested starch was going straight to the colon—yikes! Dexatrim was another pill of the era. The appetite suppressant contained the drug PPA (phenylpropanolamine), and in 2000, it too was pulled from the market. The pill was eventually reincarnated as Dexatrim Natural Ephedrine-Free, though some critics still aren’t convinced it’s safe. Our take: Unless they’re prescribed by your doctor, pills are almost never a good idea.

Reasons why men worship your body just the way you are.

1980s diet trend: Scarsdale Diet The 1980s swung away from easy fixes and back to hardcore discipline with the Scarsdale Diet. It was a two-week high-protein, low-carb and super-low-calorie diet (1,000 calories or fewer per day!). Author Herman Tarnower, M.D., claimed that by going on and off the diet every two weeks, followers could lose up to 20 pounds per week without any long-term deprivation of any vitamins or minerals. But the food list was restrictive: no butter, no salad dressing (except lemon and vinegar) and no alcohol. Your snack choices were either raw carrots or celery—that’s it. If losing 20 pounds a week sounds too good to be true, it is. For most people, consuming fewer than 1,200 calories a day is considered a starvation diet.

1990s diet trend: Low-carb Atkins
Throughout the ’80s, people became aware of red meat’s association with heart disease, so they thought carbohydrates were the answer to a longer life, says Gabriella Petrick, PhD, a food historian at New York University. “The medical knowledge at any given time gets reflected in diets prescribed,” she says. “In the ’80s, the popularity of lean chicken also exploded. And in the ’90s, the Atkins diet was a reaction against ideas in the 1980s that said you need a high-carb diet.” People who had ballooned from all the carbs fell in love with Dr. Atkins. Although he’d been around before the ’90s, his popularity soared after the book Dr. Atkins’ New Diet Revolution was released in 1992.

 Go here to see the top 5 diet trends of today!

MORE FROM GLAMOUR:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 37
  • Adel's Avatar
    Posted by Adel Thu Mar 5, 2009 1:28am PST

    adel

    Report Abuse
  • Adel's Avatar
    Posted by Adel Thu Mar 5, 2009 1:31am PST

    adel

    Report Abuse
  • annie's Avatar
    Posted by annie Thu Mar 5, 2009 3:20am PST

    I bow flex for 20 minutes every morning and have now for 18 years. I eat a cup of oatmeal every morning and drink 2 liters of water a day. I watch the sugar and salt intake and try to limit animal fats. Otherwise I pretty much eat whaever I want: I think the key to fitness and good looking skinny jeans is to have a daily fitness routine and try not to skip it. Put the word "diet" out of the vocabulary and instead think lifestyle change. It's worth it to be able to have a stable weight and lots of energy. If I overdo, I make a huge pot of vegetable soup and eat it three times a day for a week.

    Report Abuse
  • phinka's Avatar
    Posted by phinka Thu Mar 5, 2009 7:22am PST

    Personally, I don't think anything will work, unless you really try hard and are not swayed by anyone trying to make you cheat on your diet. Exercise is the key and teamed with a strong will and persistence, I am going to make it work for me this time. Not every diet works for everyone. Just keep trying and you will find your perfect fit eventually.

    Report Abuse
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Thu Mar 5, 2009 9:44am PST

    Woah Lizbeth: You are scaring me with the voodoo thing. Hahahahaha

    Report Abuse
  • Jett's Avatar
    Posted by Jett Thu Mar 5, 2009 11:51am PST

    I looked up the Cookie Diet, because the article above alluded to it but then didn't explain it (actually I'd thought it was a joke — not a real diet — but, no, people actually do it.) It claims to suppress appetite through the 6 cookies you eat throughout the day, followed by a real meal of chicken and veggies for dinner. The cookies suppress hunger because they contain oats, rice, whole wheat flour, and bran — foods that contain amino acids, fiber, and hunger-suppressing protein.

    So, why not just eat oats, brown rice, whole wheat flour, and bran??? Why spend all this money on an unhealthy diet that includes almost no vegetables and no fruit? Are people that disgusted with real food that they would buy into this just so they can eat cookies all day? I can't imagine the cookies taste all that good, if that's what they contain.

    Here's my suggestion: Have bran cereal with skim or soy milk or oatmeal (the good kind, not the sugar-laden junk) and a serving of fruit for breakfast; have low-fat yogurt and a serving of fruit for a snack; have brown rice, two servings of veggies, and some sort of protein like chicken or fish for lunch; have carrot sticks and celery and a hard-boiled egg or a serving of nuts for an afternoon snack; have a serving of homemade veggie pot pie made with whole wheat flour for dinner with a salad made of spring mix, avocado, tomatoes,other veggies you like, and a teaspoon each of olive oil and lemon juice as dressing. Then for dessert, have a handful of chocolate chips. You're still getting food that tastes good — and chocolate! — but you're also getting a really healthy meal plan. Make sure to exercise too: walk for 30 minutes three days a week, or for 20 minutes five days a week.

    (Approx. health value for day: 4 servings of protein, 3-4 servings of whole grains, 2 servings of fruit, 4-7 servings of veggies — depending on how big that salad is and how many carrots and celery you eat, amino acids from the olive oil.) Technically you should get many more servings of whole grains each day (7-10) according to the food pyramid, but it's better than eating only cookies all day.

    Here's the link to an article about the cookie diet: http://abcnews.go.com/GMA/story?id=125395&page=1

    Report Abuse
  • Jett's Avatar
    Posted by Jett Thu Mar 5, 2009 12:19pm PST

    Khaliela,

    Well, the problem with the diet, they say, is that you're consuming almost no fruits, veggies, or protein even.

    I hadn't thought about oatmeal cookies. I have made oatmeal chocolate chip cookies with whole wheat flour that were really good, but I don't know about the rice and bran as well. They sound like a cure for constipation, don't they? Ha, ha!

    Report Abuse
  • Susan's Avatar
    Posted by Susan Thu Mar 5, 2009 12:44pm PST

    Yeah, the Atkins diet is by far the wackiest diet I've heard of. Why would anyone think it's a good idea to eat mostly artery-clogging meat and cholesterol-laden eggs? Americans eat far too much protein than they need, and this diet focuses on meat! Crazy! The best diet is based on a lot of vegetables, fruit, and lean sources of protein like legumes, and steering clear of meat and dairy products.

    Report Abuse
  • Heidi's Avatar
    Posted by Heidi Thu Mar 5, 2009 10:15pm PST

    Eat whole foods, drink water instead of soda, and exercise a few times a week. It's really not all that hard. I joined a weight loss support group on myspace and stopped visiting it after about two days because the people on there were more interested in whining about being overweight than in doing anything about it.

    Report Abuse
  • Cheryl's Avatar
    Posted by Cheryl Fri Mar 6, 2009 8:41pm PST

    How about the best one of the 2000s....chocolate! www.GetChocolateWOW.com

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 37

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Are your feet aching? Do you suffer from plantar fasciitis or varicose veins? Relief could be as simple as stretching your toes.