Fashion + Beauty

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Related Topics:

Is Your Sunscreen Doing More Harm than Good?

Previously, I hadn't given much thought to what was in my sunscreen. As long as the SPF was high enough I figured I was safe right?

Not so much. Turns out all sunscreens are not created equal, and some of my faves actually contain harmful ingredients (like these) or not enough of the good stuff (UV protection). The non-profit Environmental Working Group recently released a list of the safest and most effective sunscreens -- and which ones you should steer clear of. Check out a few of the good and bad below (and see what regular users think of them too).


THE GOOD:
Badger Sunscreen, SPF 30
EWG rating: 0 (EWG ratings go from 0 to 10, 0 to 2 is recommended and 7 and above you should avoid)
TotalBeauty.com rating: 8.5 (out of 10, 10 being the best)
Why: EWG says this product has high UVA and UVB protection and high stability (meaning it won't break down and become ineffective quickly). TotalBeauty.com readers love the natural ingredients and say it's good for sensitive skin. 

Lavera Sunscreen Neutral, SPF 40
EWG rating: 1
TotalBeauty.com rating: 9
Why: EWG says this has high UVA and UVB protection and high stability. Readers say it's great for sensitive skin and they like that it's fragrance free.

California Baby Sunscreen Lotion No Fragrance, SPF 30+
EWG rating: 1
TotalBeauty.com rating: 8.3
Why: EWG says this has medium UVA protection, but high UVB protection and high stability. Readers say this can leave a white cast on skin but it's great for babies and is water resistant.

EltaMD Elta MD UV Physical, SPF 41
EWG rating: 2
TotalBeauty.com rating: 10
Why: EWG says this has high UVA and UVB protection and high stability. Readers like that it is a tinted formula (so no white cast on skin) that still has plenty of zinc to protect.

Solbar Shield Sunscreen, SPF 40
EWG rating: 2
TotalBeauty.com rating: 9
Why: EWG says this has high UVA and UVB protection and high stability. Readers love that it's not greasy and easy to apply.

Fallene Cotz Water-Resistant UVA & UVB Sun Protection, SPF 58
EWG rating: 2
TotalBeauty.com rating: 10
Why: EWG says this has high UVA protection, the highest UVB protection and high stability. Readers say this is great to use on your face or body and for men or women.

Neutrogena Sunblock Stick, SPF 60+
EWG rating: 2
TotalBeauty.com rating: 8.4
Why: EWG says this has high UVA protection, the highest UVB protection and high stability. Readers love how easy this is to carry around and that it doesn't clog pores.

THE BAD:
Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch Sunblock, SPF 30
EWG rating: 7
TotalBeauty.com rating: 8.6
Why: EWG says this has medium UVA and high UVB protection and stability, however it also has oxybenzone, a possible carcinogen. Readers still like the non-greasy finish, but some are wary of the ingredients.

Banana Boat Sport Performance UltraMist Continuous Clear Spray Sunscreen, SPF 15
EWG rating: 7
TotalBeauty.com rating: 5.3
Why: EWG says this has medium UVA and UVB protection and high stability, but it also has oxybenzone and low SPF. Readers say this spray is uneven, causing some burning and it feels greasy.

Coppertone Sport Continuous Spray, SPF 30

EWG rating: 7
TotalBeauty.com rating: 7.1
Why: EWG says this has low UVA protection, but high UVB protection and stability. It also contains oxybenzone. Readers have mixed reviews. Some love the ease of the spray, while others say the smell is terrible and it's greasy.

Dermalogica Solar Defense Wipes, SPF 15
EWG rating: 7
TotalBeauty.com rating: 8.7
Why: EWG says this has medium UVA, UVB protection and stability, plus oxybenzone and low SPF. Despite that, readers love how easy it is to apply and the lack of greasy hands. They do wish it came in a higher SPF though.

Peter Thomas Roth Ultra-lite Oil-free Sunscreen Mist, SPF 15
EWG rating: 7
TotalBeauty.com rating: 6
Why: EWG says this has low UVA and medium UVB protection and medium stability. It also has oxybenzone and low SPF. Readers say it works well, but don't like the high price.

Coppertone Oil-Free Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 15
EWG rating: 7
TotalBeauty.com rating: 8.9
Why: EWG says this has low UVA protection and medium UVB protection and stability, plus oxybenzone and low SPF. Readers like that it's light and not greasy, but say it didn't protect well in the water.

 Coppertone ultraGuard Continuous Spray Sunscreen, SPF 15
EWG rating: 8
TotalBeauty.com rating: 7.3
Why: EWG says this has low UVA protection, medium UVB protection and high stability. It also has oxybenzone and low SPF. Readers like the convenience of the spray but say the product feels like you're coated with hairspray.

Keep up with the latest in beauty -- follow us on Twitter and friend us on Facebook.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 27
  • linduhh's Avatar
    Posted by linduhh Sat Jul 11, 2009 10:28pm PDT

    well where can we even buy the "good" sunscreens? we cant break our budget

    Report Abuse
  • bria's Avatar
    Posted by bria Sun Jul 12, 2009 9:18am PDT

    well i have a concept for you guys. If there was no sunscreen just hundreds of years ago, wouldn't it make sense that we were kinda MEANT to be in the sun? The best advice I've gotten is to NOT wear sunscreen and just cover up with lightweight pants and long sleeved shirt (and a hat...very important)during the most dangerous hours in summer which is from about 10-12pm and then have at least an hour or more of sun exposure daily so then you can get your daily vitamin d...Also sunscreen looks greasy regardless whether its oily or not...my acne has gone down dramatically since I've stopped using that crap.

    Report Abuse
  • GG1000's Avatar
    Posted by GG1000 Sun Jul 12, 2009 10:26am PDT

    Katie B, we've had luck with Neutrogena's Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch, oil-free sunscreen. In general, the Neutrogena stuff's been pretty good, and I like that it doesn't sting my face.

    We all know Badger's top rated, but my kids won't let me put it on them because it's basically smearable zinc oxide, leaves white gunk everywhere and smells absolutely disgusting (if pines trees had armpits, they'd smell like Badger). There's gotta be some usability tradeoff!

    Report Abuse
  • j-log's Avatar
    Posted by j-log Sun Jul 12, 2009 11:56am PDT

    These spray sunscreens suck. I bought one and seriously got 3 uses out of it and it cost the same as a bottle of lotion sunscreen that you can easily get 10-15 uses out of.

    Report Abuse
  • JAZZ's Avatar
    Posted by JAZZ Sun Jul 12, 2009 12:29pm PDT

    NIVEA SUNBLOCK LOTION SPF 50 worked best for my children. No traces of sunburn can be seen on their even they stayed under the heat at the Batangas beach. Unlike other products I used for them, this is simply the best.

    HI TO MY 3 GOOD LOOKING BOYZ- Clark Mamasabulod-de Leon (14), Clarence (5) and Ali (3).

    MAMA LOVES U!

    Report Abuse
  • Aj's Avatar
    Posted by Aj Mon Jul 13, 2009 11:07am PDT

    Thanks alot for this information!

    Report Abuse
  • Katie B's Avatar
    Posted by Katie B Mon Jul 13, 2009 11:33am PDT

    GG1000 thanks for the info... I will have to try that out then...

    Report Abuse
  • Jo's Avatar
    Posted by Jo Mon Jul 13, 2009 6:15pm PDT

    I strongly recommend that people do not get their information about sunscreens from a "Fashion and Beauty" blog. The Neutrogena product that is on this "bad" list is an excellent product. In addition, for those people with medium to dark skin an SPF15 is appropriate and generally adequate for at least 6 hours of sun exposure.

    Report Abuse
  • Alexandra's Avatar
    Posted by Alexandra Mon Jul 13, 2009 7:19pm PDT

    This whole thing is so true. I have a really bad allergy to some of the chemicals in certain sunscreens particularly high level ones. So i HAVE to use the smaller SPF.

    Report Abuse
  • TasselLady's Avatar
    Posted by TasselLady Tue Jul 14, 2009 3:53pm PDT

    I used to use Coppertone suncreen 45. I burn very easily so I have to have a good sunscreen. I don't know if the others are any good or not. But I always check it out before I buy it. I'll have the lobster thing going without it!! ha Ha!!! But it's important for people who burn and not tan to use something to protect their skin. You don't want to get skin cancer.

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 27

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

High Gloss Hair Color in 10 Minutes

Perfect 10: Most awarded hair color by Beauty Editors.